It’s a loyalty test. If you follow the insane order you are loyal.
The failure modes of autocracies are more obvious: bad kings, low information decision making, incompetent bureaucrats, and no way to remove them peacefully without waiting for them to die.
"Matter" is unfortunately correct both then and now: the word does not imply objective correctness.
That said, from his position I’m absolutely certain it looks super-intelligent… come to think of it, I’m kind of surprised the shibboleth isn’t “mega-hyper-giga-plaid-intelligence”.