13 pointsby IvanK_net3 hours ago6 comments
  • JohnFena minute ago
    You should discuss this with an attorney that is experienced with IP law to see what your options are, if any. IP law is very complex and often things that seem like they should be legal/illegal are not. You need expert legal advice, not the advice from the HN audience.
  • aetherspawn34 minutes ago
    I think what you want is a legal avenue, like Trademark, Design rights, or patent.

    If you have one of these, it’s possible that GitHub would honour it if you go via a lawyer.

  • B4uler53 hours ago
    Sorry this happened to you dude. I don’t want to be harsh but, out of the crimes ignored in this era of AI clean rooming, book destroying distilleries and a despondent ostrich adjacent legal system you do seem to be one amongst a deluge of cheated individuals.

    Hope you manage to get it sorted but I have no idea how that would go down at this point. I’m sure at least one of them could claim they copied it off the other ones and then you’re shit out of luck.

  • ianberdin3 hours ago
    I personally know Ivan. For many years of his life, every day, he programmed algorithm after algorithm in this complex online photo editing tool. Essentially, he devoted half his life to it. And now, when someone has literally stolen his work, nobody is reacting. And that's terrible. I think it's absolutely terrible. GitHub should respond to this.

    I've seen people on Reddit writing things like, "Come on, what's the big deal? AI can write any code now." I disagree. There are hundreds of thousands of lines of code here, very complex code, which even AI wouldn't be able to write on the first try or in a single day. So this person stole this code from Photopea and built a product on top of it.

    • sneak23 minutes ago
      Copying isn’t stealing. We settled this in the 90s.
      • flourish_dev15 minutes ago
        Yeah, this bodes well for my meditation app frontend I'm going to release on GitHub. It should be fair use ish but it does seem GitHub is fairly friendly anyway.
  • rvz3 hours ago
    > What do you think I could do? Do you think I should look for a lawyer to deal with it outside the digital world?

    Use a trademark.

    • nixrobot2 hours ago
      How will that help? Trademarks do not protect code - only logos, names, brands. And brands are easy to remove.

      Something else is needed. If the code is basically open, then there is no technical protection. Remove tens of those repos - hundreds might appear.

    • IvanK_net2 hours ago
      Wow, that might actually work, thanks!
  • verdverman hour ago
    There are 100s of web based photo editors, paid and open source. How do you know they are taking yours, not someone else's or making their own with Ai?

    I would imagine they all converge on common features and core implementation foundation