2 pointsby barry-cotter4 hours ago1 comment
  • barry-cotter4 hours ago
    > The genetic arguments in the book draw the most criticism and yet the book has much else offer as Clark notes. For example:

    >>Social status is inherited as strongly as height. Even relatives as distant as nine generations apart, 270 years, still show significant correlation in social status.

    > That is a very striking finding–especially given the intervening industrial revolution, multiple wars, huge changes in social mores etc.–but if it stands, it does so independent of the genetic explanation.

    > The fact that this monumental and challenging book–right or wrong–cannot find a major academic publisher is an intellectual scandal. The editors at Princeton University Press and the University of Chicago Press should be ashamed.

    https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/10/th...