26 pointsby xnx6 hours ago3 comments
  • ncr10044 minutes ago
    Why is immigration high?

    I expect the answer has to do wit higher populations, easier transport, increased knowledge of emmigration opportunities via presence of the Internet, climate change, and globalization.

    ?

    • rayiner38 minutes ago
      At bottom, it's politics. Most people in Asia, Africa, and the Middle East have a top-down, paternalistic view of government compared to western europeans and in particular Americans. So political parties who support a paternalistic government are heavily incentivized to increase immigration to gain voting power over their political rivals. It's basic math.
      • BoiledCabbage28 minutes ago
        That's the type of comment people make when they don't want to understand what the others side's actual views are, so instead they tell themselves a simple story they can believe rather than engage with the actual reason.

        Both sides do it, but that's a prime example of one of the popular ones from one side.

  • purplepatrick3 hours ago
    The content of this article doesn’t show what the title says.

    Neither the foreign-born population nor the proportion of foreign-born individuals say anything about the “current immigration”.

    But I guess it works, because nowhere is “immigration” defined either…

  • vivzkestrelan hour ago
    - arent native americans the only real american?

    - isnt everyone else just an immigrant?

    • rayiner41 minutes ago
      No, because the "United States" is the name of a country--a man-made entity--not just a label for an outline on a map. That country was made by a specific group of people, who brought over their language, culture, laws, and political philosophy. Those people were settlers and founders. The people who came into that pre-existing society are immigrants.

      I'm a Bangladeshi immigrant married to an Anglo-American. Almost everything about America reflects her culture, not mine. At home, we speak the language her ancestors spoke, not mine. We're both lawyers. We deal with concepts her ancestors developed over the past 800 years, not mine. Our kids grow up learning things like individualism, which is a concept her ancestors developed, not mine. She's descended from settlers, whereas I'm an immigrant. It's like the Last Samurai, where Tom Cruise's character settles down with the Japanese woman. He's an immigrant, but she's not an immigrant--even though technically Yamato people came to Japan from the Korean peninsula: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yayoi_people.

      In fact it's even starker because the United States borrows almost nothing from the Indian nations that existed on the land before it, while the Jomon people had a much larger influence on present-day Japan.

    • s1artibartfastan hour ago
      No, many people people are born in the usa, having never lived elsewhere.
    • ImJamalan hour ago
      The definition of native is "Being such by birth or origin.". This means that everybody born in the US are native Americans.