48 pointsby Bluestein3 hours ago15 comments
  • deepllm2 hours ago
    Stock Fedora or nearly all the other Linux distributions are a thousand times more stable and secure than Omarachy is.

    https://xn--gckvb8fzb.com/a-word-on-omarchy/

    • steve19772 hours ago
      Well I guess that's the problem with

      > getting something beautifully curated and integrated from someone they trust to make competent, tasteful decisions

    • pelagicAustral2 hours ago
      To me, personally, the value of Omarchy is more like a pre-riced developer environment, nothing else, and I am totally cool with that. Some people say it's not a distro, but then again, that would mean that kubuntu is also not a distro... btw, I work with fedora, so take my posture on this with a pinch of salt.
    • anon573948338 minutes ago
      > Published on 2025-10-22 and updated on 2025-11-08

      Article is very outdated.

  • bestham2 hours ago
    I’m very impressed with how easy Omarchy is to get going for someone who knows enough about Linux and computers to take over the rudder and steer the ship to wherever they are going. Proprietary tools like 1Password and Spotify are in place. It works wonderful in a Mac centric SaaS organisation. Actively developed and refined. It would be great to have a traditional taskbar oriented distro like this. But in the meantime I can run this and forget about my OS for a while.
    • 2ash12g2 hours ago
      You are absolutely right and thank you for your level headed response! Omarchy genuinely provides value to our organization. It isn't just a Linux distribution---it is a political statement!
      • thefossguy69an hour ago
        What even is this comment?
        • deepllman hour ago
          I think it might just be DHH creating a new account (49 minutes old) to glaze Omarchy.
  • crocowhile2 hours ago
    This is not a distro. It's a masterpiece in trolling.
    • rmoriz2 hours ago
      It's a top to bottom approach. Get the UI/UX working, make incredible marketing, sort out the technical foundation later. Excellent executed from a strategic point of view. Let's see if Arch is the best foundation for such a project. I don't know.

      Personally, I hope, Debian isn't shutting the door on LLM-supported coding to improve their legacy tooling. I believe we have a very short window to use almost-free LLM fixing internal debt and outstanding issues with our FOSS setup.

      • crocowhilean hour ago
        Over the past 30 years I have witnessed multiple approaches to try and capture the normies. Ubuntu was the first one to try and market a "just works" approach, introducing a graphical package manager that looked like the play store or apple store; Mint was trying to clone the Windows or MacOS appearance. Then there was the Compiz frenzy, that was selling graphical features as eye candies. They all had their reason to exist.

        Omarchy, on the other hand, is this close to be a scam: marketed as "the AI distro" just because it has a keyboard shortcut to launch claude-code or codex basically. "opinionated" because it ships with a default desktop manager and a default text editor, just like any other freaking distro out there. Not to mention the fact that it's financed by people who have nothing to do with FOSS.

        • TiredOfLife40 minutes ago
          > marketed as "the AI distro"

          Where?

  • Retr0id2 hours ago
    I'm a fan of omakase computing but in an "install stock fedora or debian" sense. I find the maintainers have great taste. I'm not sure any more ink needs to be spilt than that.
  • atonsean hour ago
    I just installed Omarchy yesterday wanting to try it out. Mainly dealing with not having a mouse for my second computer but maybe you gotta give it a few days as your main machine.

    But I prefer the sub pixel font rendering in macOS to the one in Linux. I always have. And that hasn’t changed with Omarchy.

    The theo video about the file systems being way faster is what got me to consider it. Working with node modules folders a lot, and occasionally working with docker (orbstack is great) I’m curious about considering this as my dev machine.

    We’ll see how it goes but I wasn’t blown away the way the videos say. At least not yet.

  • elil173 hours ago
    I have no idea how to navigate to the homepage of this website
    • Bluestein3 hours ago
      - https://learn.omacom.io/

      (It is not very discoverable? The "bookshelf-like" icon on top ...)

      • polonbike3 hours ago
        Please use standard hamburger menu icon or equivalent. The bookshelf icon does not represent a menu or a navigation indication.
        • Gualdrapo2 hours ago
          In all fairness that would be a really weird bookshelf icon with "books" with no shelves and the few books it has are floating somehow in the top left corner of it. I bet it's more of a "sidebar menu" icon.

          Though yes, it would be much better a hamburger icon - or just having that sidebar menu open as default.

      • kibibu2 hours ago
        This website sucks so bad, holy cow
      • elil1737 minutes ago
        [dead]
  • logicallee3 hours ago
    I do this with Claude. I don't add skills files, since I figure if they worked that well then Anthropic would just put it in Claude code.

    I just open Claude in a new directory (no agents.md file or claude.md file), tell it what I'd like it to build, and figure that Anthropic would give it any tooling it needs. If some skill etc worked so great, it would just be part of Claude Code.

    (However, I do think it writes some memories based on things that worked well or poorly before - it does really well at projects now, I think it does much better than a stock installation, so I think it does make use of memory files. I see its notes when it writes certain lessons to memory.)

  • JSR_FDED2 hours ago
    Listened to DHH on The Primeagen’s The Standup podcast - talking about how Macs are complete trash and can’t be used “for agents”. Like a dumb marketing droid parroting some inane talking points his VP has come up with to sound “AI relevant”.
    • _waqas_ali_2 hours ago
      I watched the same and I didn’t hear any marketing speak. He’s excited about his ideas, puts in the work and genuinely trying to make Linux accessible.

      About calling Mac trash, I think he should have added “for engineers”. I like/use macOS and Omarchy both and they are meant for different audiences.

    • Aurornisan hour ago
      > talking about how Macs are complete trash and can’t be used “for agents”.

      DHH has always been a contrarian who speaks highly confidently in extremes. He does well in topics where he can show up and act like a beacon of sane and helpful takes in a world where everyone other than him is wrong.

      Some times he’ll find a clear wedge topic and hook his message to that, appealing to people on one side of the wedge.

      At other times he’ll manufacture some strawman arguments and present them as indisputable facts that he’s revealing to you, dear listener, as a trusted guide who has seen the light.

      His sudden flip to being anti-Mac after years of being pro-Mac follows the pattern. He had some small real grievance at some point and saw an opportunity to become known for Omarchy, so he flipped to extreme takes like “Macs are complete trash” and saying weird things like how they can’t be used for agents.

    • cfiggers2 hours ago
      In that podcast DHH was talking about how in Omarchy you can change the system settings, monitor setup, themes, window chrome, installed programs, window manager config, keyboard shortcuts, etc. using agents. This is facilitated by Omarchy because all that stuff is dictated by text files that agents can directly interface with.

      Whatever the merits of MacOS, and there are many, it is not the paradigm there that all your system settings and config are stored in text files. That's what he was talking about.

      • JSR_FDED2 hours ago
        You can use the ‘defaults’ CLI to manage settings files for the OS and applications.

        For example: https://macos-defaults.com/

        • hizanberg2 hours ago
          Other than being a proprietary OS that's getting more locked down every year, its disk performance is trash.

          https://x.com/theo/status/2090528543746965991

          • Aurornisan hour ago
            Do you have a non-video, non-X summary of what he’s talking about?

            I’m not watching a 31 minute video on X to figure out what this is about. Theo is another influencer who thrives on being contrarian, embellishing negative claims about things he’s not pumping right now, and trying to get everyone to ignore negative things about what he is pumping. I would not trust his judgment on topics like this without some third party benchmarks and deeper claims because the first priority of influencers in this category is to be contrarian and ride divisive topics. Being factually correct is secondary.

            • hombre_fatal34 minutes ago
              Lots of small fs operations on macOS is apparently rough.

              I use nix on macOS and any time it's making changes to /nix/store, the Finder and fsevents processes peg cpu.

              IIRC his video shows fs-heavy ops like file deltions and pnpm install taking much longer on a macbook despite better specs.

              Frankly, things like the lack of a universal cmd-c/v clipboard on linux has been 1000x worse for usability than slower bulk fs.

          • Doctor_Fegg2 hours ago
            Ah, the irony of posting "Your Mac is slowing you down" on the bloated JS hellsite that is X. That page took 10s to appear on my machine (before even thinking of rendering the video) whereas the HN front page is <1s.
      • msdz2 hours ago
        > Whatever the merits of MacOS, and there are many, it is not the paradigm there that all your system settings and config are stored in text files.

        Maybe not, but the agent can call `defaults write` too, no?

      • lightedman2 hours ago
        "it is not the paradigm there that all your system settings and config are stored in text files."

        This is inherently untrue. A .plist in XML is nothing but text. It might be formatted text, but it is still text nonetheless, like almost every other configuration file in existence.

        • anon573948321 minutes ago
          Technically correct but you miss the point. Human readable text (like TOML). Nobody wants to edit XML .plist files to configure their OS and apps.
  • 34ksh162 hours ago
    DHH had been anti AI first. Then he got a board seat at Shopify. Shopify needs to maintain the AI narrative to maintain the illusion of easy shop creation.

    Now DHH pushes AI in a simple Linux distribution, one of millions of others. And the money flows in.

    Why would DHH want to keep foreigners out if he wants to make everyone unemployed? The same applies to Musk. It is interesting that these two figures support DEI when it comes to unemployment: Everyone but snowboarders (Lütke) and "race car drivers" (DHH) should be unemployed regardless of skin color! True equality!

  • embedding-shape3 hours ago
    > classic Linux culture. Where there's been a strong belief that everyone should know everything about all of their tools, and that they should preferably configure every last one from them from scratch.

    Huh, what Linux culture is this Ruby-on-Rails fanboi talking about? Arch Linux I guess comes closest to it, but still isn't "everyone has to know everything about all tools", but I guess if you're launching some closed source platform or whatever the author is up to, you probably want it to sound like Linux forces you to know everything about everything, so you can sell your service to the people who don't want that. Good luck I guess.

    This reads as a blogpost from someone who is mad at Linux for some reason, yet cannot fully describe why?

    • aquariusDue2 hours ago
      Yeah... KDE, GNOME and soon COSMIC will be fine for most people. Ricing IS fun but this is more similar to taking a kitted out car that used to belong to your cousin to the car meet, part of the culture is stumbling around forums and asking around. There's been stuff in the past like Regolith that did similar things but now a semi-famous person is spearheading this so everybody wooos and ahhhs.

      Yes, I am salty.

    • hombre_fatal2 hours ago
      He's talking about Linux neckbeards and gatekeepers, not, say, cultural idiosyncrasies of any given distro.
      • embedding-shapean hour ago
        None of them, at least the one's I've encountered in my 20 something years, have had the idea of "everyone has to know everything about all tools", although they've certainly been annoying in other ways.
        • hombre_fatalan hour ago
          There's some hyperbole but his point is obvious to me from hanging out in forums and IRC channels over the years, or reading snarky "umm, I'm confused...?" quote-tweets for certain Omarchy posts about how Omarchy is just quickshell hyprland rice.

          I used to use an old omakase version of Debian called Crunchbang in uni (https://crunchbang.org/) and there was always someone around to make the remark that you'd only use it if you couldn't read manpages.

          Or Dropbox seems pointless because you can build it trivially by mounting an ftp location with curlftpfs + svn.

    • skydhash2 hours ago
      >> classic Linux culture. Where there's been a strong belief that everyone should know everything about all of their tools,

      That’s weird, imagine saying to mechanics, artists,… to not learn all about their tools.

    • lightedman2 hours ago
      "Huh, what Linux culture is this Ruby-on-Rails fanboi talking about?"

      Probably Gentoo, since that's where the truly competent Linux users that do understand their tools tend to migrate.

    • kibibu2 hours ago
      > Ruby-on-Rails fanboi

      Lol. The author is the creator of Rails

      • embedding-shapean hour ago
        Lol, he should try signing his post, literally had no idea! Thought it was weird to fanboi so much over someone else's framework, but now it totally makes sense, DHH has a tendency to toot his own horn a lot.
  • fwip2 hours ago
    Omarchy is AI slop from an outspoken racist. Use a real distro.
  • ubermonkey2 hours ago
    DHH means this is, for me, a hard pass.
  • wekalpc2 hours ago
    It is 2026 and you can still sell the old "my opinionated Linux distribution" to cult members and investors. DHH is laughing all the way to the bank.
  • dagi3d3 hours ago
    [flagged]
    • hyperbolablabla2 hours ago
      This kind of trite partisan comment does not belong on HN imo.
      • herrherrmann2 hours ago
        I disagree. Technology is inherently political, and it’s valuable and important to get informed and reminded about the many horrible people that are directly or indirectly tied to any mentioned organizations and projects.
      • froggertoaster2 hours ago
        Sadly, HN has increasingly become an echo chamber for 90% of the same kinds of partisan politics.
      • catlover762 hours ago
        [dead]
    • magistr4te2 hours ago
      That's a good one, got a laugh out of me!
    • Bjartr3 hours ago
      I skimmed their Wikipedia page and I can't figure out how they relate to this post. What's the connection?
    • 2 hours ago
      undefined
    • hokumguru2 hours ago
      Honestly who cares. Liking and using an open source project has nothing to do with supporting the creators political beliefs. Separate the art from the artist and enjoy things. This miserable attitude is holding us all back from being better.
      • herrherrmann2 hours ago
        Many people care and should care. Of course if a piece of software (or any project/tool, really) gets a lot of usage, it’ll indirectly make its creators more powerful. I wouldn’t want to make a person more powerful if they support horrible causes (like in DHH’s case), especially if there are many alternative routes to choose from that are less questionable.
      • shafyy2 hours ago
        You can separate the art from the artist in the sense that you can say "ok, this is a cool tech", but by using it, you are still supporting the nazi artist.
    • adamtaylor_132 hours ago
      You should spend less time seething over stuff you disagree with, and more time enjoying beautiful things in life...

      Like Omakase.

  • dec0dedab0de2 hours ago
    I love Omakase, but not because I don’t know what I want.

    It is because I want to experience an artist’s work.