The issue I have is, what is the subject? For instance, you have a person sat on a couch. You hit Select Subject. Is the subject the person, or the person plus the couch?
With Adobe's when I only want the person, most of the time Select Subject works, and when it doesn't I can pivot to Select Person, but that has its own problem because it won't include props that the subject is holding, only the person and their clothing.
> what is the subject?
FeyNoBg is an "automatic" model. It automatically detects foreground elements and segments the image. Most of the time, this includes all foreground elements. As you can see in the freekick example (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1MZkAGLwbhNVOZ0Oi7XvpCfSEu9Q...), the model output includes the ball, Messi, and the Liverpool defenders. In your example, FeyNoBg will segment around the person plus the couch.
> I only want the person [including props]
The alternative to automatic models are prompt models and those serve the exact use case you're describing. These allow you to specify the foreground element to include. Everything else is removed. That's the next step for FeyNoBg, converting it from an automatic to a prompt model. Now, answering your question:
> How does it stack up against Adobe's model?
We're better on automatic background removal. Support for selecting a subset of foreground elements is coming soon
I love seeing maturity getting pushed in this space. Congratulations to you and the team!
We've released projects under the MIT license before, most notably https://github.com/feyninc/chonkie. While we're not trying to directly monetize on this work, credit goes a long way and helps in other operations.
Recently, attributed usage is shrinking. To be clear, this is not a shrinkage in actual use of our software, just how many people acknowledge that they rely on it.
cc-by-nc is a protection against that. We've been very honest about our work being on top of BiRefNet as we want to extend the original creators the same courtesy. I have no issues if individuals fork/finetune/or otherwise build on top of any open source projects we release, irrespective of license. At minimum, we want acknowledgment if a company chooses to use our software in production.
https://github.com/KupynOrest/s3od
All I ask is you make a PR to https://github.com/feyninc/nobg with your results. We'd love to see what you make, contribute in any way we can, and share onwards.
Of course, it's impossible to know for sure what was LLM processed or not, but some of your posts (like this one) have been getting classified that way.