Memanto; open-source memory agent that remembers, recalls and answers(github.com)
14 pointsby majidfekri6 hours ago5 comments
  • lemmingstarsan hour ago
    This tool is amazing, pretty innovative way to store memory for agents.
  • harveney5 hours ago
    Good that it's open source, though always sus about what they actually do. I've seen a lot of supposed memory layers end up just being a RAG system with remember and recall over pg_vector or something. I'll admit I haven't really looked into the code to verify whether that's actually the case so open to being fact checked.
    • majidfekri5 hours ago
      I assure you it is not a vibe coded pg_vector wrapper. It is built on top of a custom made search engine that is state-of-the-art in semantic search. Check out moorcheh.ai, cloud infrastructure, moorcheh on-prem and moorcheh-on-edge. Here is the paper explaining how we came up with the idea of memanto: https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.22085
      • harveney5 hours ago
        Thanks for the reply! So you've actually built your own custom vector DB on top of the memory layer? That's definitely something new.

        I'm honestly not sold on memory layers as a whole, I find that adding more context only serves to make the LLM's dumber and I've been slowly leaning towards just having no memory and working on features in isolation.

        You've done benchmarks already so that's another step in the right direction, do you find that these benchmarks are good indications of practicality? Have you seen a major difference in LLM performance utilizing this as a memory layer?

        • majidfekri4 hours ago
          To answer your first question, I have to say no. agentic memory benchmarks do not reflect the nuances and difficulties that real agents encounter in real workflows. We hope there are better more practical benchmarks being developed. Second question I assume by LLM you mean AI agents; if that is the case, yes, the whole agentic work experience is different when you have an active memory agent to rely on.
  • h3t086 hours ago
    I first tried it last week, since then i migrated to this seek thing, really good on recall and easy to manage and maintain. We definitely need our data to be owned by us!
    • majidfekri6 hours ago
      I am so glad you like it :) your comment made my day!
  • neelbuilds6 hours ago
    I was impressed by their unique approach. They just use a vector store without any LLM for ingestion, and it still works.
  • MSTthearchitect5 hours ago
    migrating to Memanto.... it’s exactly the long-term memory layer we needed.
    • majidfekri5 hours ago
      Thanks for your comment but Memanto is not a "memory layer" it is an active "memory agent". The difference is that memanto is not a passive layer it is an actual agent and it has its own intelligence and AI capabilities independent of your agents.