This isn’t the controversy the title suggests. Taking the dev at their word, the measures are pretty reasonable; they asked for help maintaining, nobody stepped up, and so it needs funding somehow. You only need a license to access a release binary, and a paid license to access the Pro binary. Source code is open, compile it yourself to avoid. Some features went into the Paid tier: well, something had to. Commenters are mostly supportive.

The dev did yank the previous releases, which wasn’t maybe the wrong choice.

This is a horrible title. The developer has kept the entire source code open and you can build from source to get all paid features, and offers a free 14 day trial for all new users. The core functionality of Alt Tab to switch windows is staying free.

As a current free-tier user, this price & transition plan seems completely reasonable. I'll upgrade when the nudge comes. I've got at least that much utility from it so far. Very glad this isn't a subscription.

This app has been in my kit for many years now and I will buy a license the very day it goes on sale.

Pretty reasonable. Happy to pay for this, I can't stand using Macos without it.

but anyone can take this code, build any features you want on top of it without paying the author.

the titular feature is still free and strong!

the titular feature is still free and strong!