55 pointsby pretext7 hours ago2 comments
  • Kwpolska6 hours ago
    Where are the notes in this post? I can only see a bunch of quotes and zero original thought of the author.
    • aabhay6 hours ago
      When you took notes in class was it required of you to add original thought for it to be notes?
      • Kwpolska6 hours ago
        Taking notes in class is akin to making a transcript of what the teacher said in class so you can remember and refer to what was said in class. The encyclical is a written document, so there is no need for a transcript, and "notes" implies commentary and analysis.
    • nilirl6 hours ago
      HN has influencers like any other community. In this case, the upvotes are for the author and not the post.
    • KPGv26 hours ago
      Quote selection is, of course, representative of original thought of the author.
      • the-grump6 hours ago
        Still they are not notes, which means GP continues to be valid.
  • esperent6 hours ago
    Earlier post on the actual Vatican document

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48265206