233 pointsby tekkertje4 hours ago15 comments
  • m4633 minutes ago
    I wasn't familiar with haiku os, so:

    Haiku is a community-driven continuation of BeOS, a discontinued operating system for personal computers. It is binary-compatible with BeOS, but also supports contemporary systems, protocols, hardware, and web standards. - wikipedia

  • antics92 hours ago
    This weekend I installed Haiku on my old Thinkpad X40. It’s fast and surprisingly stable. Emacs, VLC works like a charm. Computer to slow for web browsing. The BeProductive office suite is a masterpiece of application at a 9MB download; although not open source.

    Then I installed Haiku on my XPS13 under KVM/Qemu. Everything runs blazingly fast. I’m thinking of maybe using that install for organizing my photos. The metadata functionality built into the BeFS is great for that.

    I must say that I am really impressed.

    • HerbManican hour ago
      Haiku is a good example of prioritising the user experience over benchmarks. Under the hood, broadly speaking, it is running at about 60% the speed of Linux on the same system. But in action it feels so much quicker than anything else.

      That is not to say that they aren't focusing on performance gains, just that they have ensured the user experience is the top priority.

    • tecleandor2 hours ago
      Oh, now you say that, I could install it on a very old VAIO I have around...
  • OhMeadhbh2 hours ago
    Was just explaining to my offspring about how Apple was looking to buy Be Inc. back before Jobs returned and they allowed themselves to be bought by NeXT. Sort of a fun complete-circle: Be ports BeOS to PowerMacs, Apple passes on buying Be, Be Inc. fades into the distance, HaikuOS kicks off, 20+ years later they port HaikuOS to Apple hardware.

    Honestly... my problem with Apple laptops isn't the hardware, it's the crappy version of XNU/Darwin/NextStep that comes with them. I would buy a Mac if it came with HaikuOS and supported all the peripherals. But what is the chance of that?

    FWIW... I still have a powermac with "real" BeOS on it. Haven't booted it in several years. I did look at HaikuOS running on an X86-64 VM and for the tasks I gave it (compile a few package, run emacs, serve a web page or two) it worked like a champ. I think the developer docs could use some help, but maybe I should volunteer to help them out.

  • guyzero3 hours ago
    Sad that we'll probably never be able to run this on M1/M-series iPads.
    • asdff3 hours ago
      So sad to me how combative Apple has been towards open source software over the years. The peak of the jailbreak era was imo peak mobile development too. So much innovation and rapid iteration. Anything seemed possible and anything really was possible if you put your mind to it and built the thing. Pretty much any good idea apple integrated into ios has been shamelessly copied without attribute from that crucible of creativity that is the jailbreak community.

      But it all hinged on someone coming up with an exploit and releasing it free to the community ignoring any bug bounty. True altruists. And apple is good enough at whack a mole and paying people $100k that this sort of effort died out. Most low hanging fruit all picked and patched already. It is no wonder that ios innovation has also stalled out now that there isn't someone to copy good ideas from any longer.

      • mghackerlady2 hours ago
        It sucks because for a while, at least in the second jobs era, they seemed to at least hesitantly support foss. They collaborated with KDE, released darwin as free software, and contributed to GCC and then very heavily to LLVM. MacOS, for a while, used an open source init system (systemstarter for a while, then launchd)
      • cute_boi2 hours ago
        I am sure government can regulate such things like they can force Apple to open up their walled garden.
        • asdff2 hours ago
          It would be refreshing if anyone in government cared about such things.
        • bigyabai2 hours ago
          Which governments, though? The US loves these "NOBUS" companies, enforcing Google and Apple's walled garden is part of their agenda.

          The hardline opposition like China, Russia and North Korea all have contingency ecosystems they'd rather promote than force Apple to comply with an arbitrary featureset. The EU, for all the good it has done, will have to contend with the US refusing to extend FVEY intelligence to states that resist cooperation.

          • solumunus2 hours ago
            The four other eyes are most likely already excluding the US at this point given that sharing intelligence with the US almost certainly means sharing it with your enemies.
            • bigyabai2 hours ago
              I doubt that. Most of those governments still rely on US-made software and US-designed hardware, so the NSA's Sword of Damocles is always dangling over their head whether or not their cooperate. The Canadian Sikh murders seem to indicate a level of US-Canada intelligence cooperation that still operates well.

              My original statement should have read Nine Eyes or Fourteen Eyes, but the point stands. The US can play hardball behind closed doors and make these nations regret regulation even if it's a good policy.

          • solumunus2 hours ago
            The four eyes are most likely already excluding the US at this point.
        • jmusall2 hours ago
          My hopes are high that the EU will be able to do this some day (unless it's fully enshittified first -- see chat control, age verification etc.)
      • HerbManican hour ago
        [dead]
    • jak02 hours ago
      [dead]
  • bmurphy19764 hours ago
    How usable is Haiku OS in practice?
    • easeout2 hours ago
      It's a delight to use, if a little esoteric at first. After the experiment phase, the software ecosystem comes up fairly limited. But I recommend visiting.

      Here are some more impressions: https://kconner.com/2025/03/09/haiku-os-study-path.html

      • OhMeadhbh2 hours ago
        +1

        The window manager might look a little old-fashioned, but it seems solid as a dev workstation.

      • freedomben2 hours ago
        What kind of hardware do you run it on? Has driver support been an issue?
        • HerbManican hour ago
          I run it on an old Optiplex that is a 3rd gen i3. No issue with drivers but that comes from its old (well seasoned) age.
        • easeout2 hours ago
          I briefly emulated it with UTM (QEMU) on macOS; the host was an M1 series chip. This story is the first indication that I might run Haiku on that machine's bare metal someday.
    • jonhohle3 hours ago
      I was trying to set up an install for my HS age some to learn programming this summer with minimal distractions. I was surprised to see IntelliJ runs and they’ve integrated GNU core utils. A hello world program ran fine.
    • makz2 hours ago
      Lack of applications is my main problem
    • altairprime3 hours ago
      On M1 on specific? or on any platform in general?
      • bmurphy197636 minutes ago
        The platform itself. Like, can it run Firefox? Can I actually do normal stuff in the browser like watch a YouTube video or join a Zoom call? Can I run VSCode? Can I run Docker?
  • OhMeadhbh2 hours ago
    Was recently looking at the FuriPhone (linux phone that runs Debian) and now I'm thinking it would be a fun project to port HaikuOS to it.
    • fsfloveran hour ago
      Doesn't it have closed drivers making porting hard? Perhaps you could consider porting it to Pinephone?
  • 3 hours ago
    undefined
  • QuercusMax35 minutes ago
    Is it only M1 macs, or are other M-series supported too (or maybe they were previously)?

    Hard to tell if this is a major breakthrough or just an incremental improvement.

  • larholm3 hours ago
    You can also try out a demo in your browser at https://distrosea.com/select/haiku/
    • altairprime3 hours ago
      M1 is not listed at this URL for me?
      • reed12343 hours ago
        This is to see what the distro is like, not to see if it’s stable on apple silicon
    • 3 hours ago
      undefined
  • sedatk3 hours ago
    Using BeOS was a fantastic experience in 1999, and it's sad that it hasn't caught on. I'm rooting for all OSes that bring different perspectives to the OS world instead of being another textbook Unix variant.

    My only qualm is how HaikuOS, and AmigaOS for that matter, fail to carry over their aesthetics to a high-resolution/HiDPI world. I see gradients, overly-empahsized embosses in the UI screenshots. They lack the serene feeling of their user interfaces from 25 years ago, and feel like DVD menus now. I used to feel the same about KDE, but it has since moved on from flashy rendering AFAIR.

    What I mean isn't to adopt a completely flat design, which I also dislike, but for instance, Windows 11's UI seems easier on the eyes than Haiku now.

    I also know that UI is hard, no question about it. All the good luck and best wishes to the team.

    • anthk3 hours ago
      Haiku has a flat theme.
    • 3 hours ago
      undefined
    • 3 hours ago
      undefined
  • oompydoompy744 hours ago
    Neat! Not sure why the comments on this post are immediately asking if it’s useful. Not everything has to be immediately useful to exist. Kill the capitalist in your head.
    • nozzlegear3 hours ago
      > Kill the capitalist in your head.

      Who referenced capitalism? And do anarchists, socialists, communists, et al., never question the usefulness of a thing either?

      • asdff3 hours ago
        The difference is those groups promote culture for culture's sake. Capitalism does not. Culture is only promoted if there is profit to be made off promoting it. As such what culture exists is severely inorganic and dependent on market forces rather than being some proxy of the actual ideaspace of the community.
        • mghackerlady2 hours ago
          well, to be pedantic, stalinist tendencies of socialism (and leninist inspired movements as a whole), tend to prioritise culture as a way to communicate the ideals of the party.

          Capitalism, in its most pure form, puts profit before anything else in any form of work

          • asdff2 hours ago
            It isn't as heavy handed as people might have assumed. I can't find the exact quote now but there is one from a filmmaker saying they had more creative freedom under the USSR than the US. In the USSR there were some things you couldn't talk about directly but subtext was often fine. In the US there was that going on as well, but you also had the need for the film to make money and merchandize other downstream products and businesses that lead to a loss of absolute creative control in favor of supporting these efforts.
            • mghackerladyan hour ago
              I believe it was George Lucas talking about some soviet friends
              • asdffan hour ago
                Thanks. I was even going to mention how George made some decisions in star wars arguably to further toy sales.
      • Matl3 hours ago
        I mean it's not hard to understand where the author is coming from. It seems like these days even a hobby project has to meet some kind of 'is there a market for it' threshold of justifying its existence.

        So your parent may've taken the 'is it useful' comments to mean 'if not, why even exist' but I got the sense they're more from people who are considering an install, even if just in a VM.

      • Computer0an hour ago
        Bro you're not killing him...
    • 3 hours ago
      undefined
    • 4 hours ago
      undefined
    • torstenvl2 hours ago
      > Kill the capitalist in your head.

      > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle.

      https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

    • SirFatty4 hours ago
      If it's not useful, then why create it?
      • dgellow4 hours ago
        What a depressing thing to read on _hacker_ news of all places

        You might want to read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_culture

        • applfanboysbgon3 hours ago
          It's just a name, after all. More accurately, this site would be titled VC Incubator News.
          • stuaxo3 hours ago
            And how boring it would be if that's all it was.
        • mghackerlady2 hours ago
          Are you telling me hacker news isn't just for advertising vibe coded slop services as a get rich quick scheme? Impossible, why did claude put it in my marketing.md then? (/s in case it isn't obvious)
        • bigyabai3 hours ago
          HN isn't reddit, for better and for worse. This is the "Orange Site" that gave us Sam Altman, defends monopolies and shits out thousands of net-negative SaaS startups that leech off Open Source software. Manufacture of depression is one of YC's byproducts that everyone loves to ignore while berating Flock and 9 Mothers like they spontaneously popped into existence.

          Your peers on this website are not principled, fun-loving Freenode/Libera geeks. HN is the Linkdin of underground social networking.

      • noja4 hours ago
        This is unexpectedly one of the saddest comments I have ever read here.
        • sunaookami3 hours ago
          The "everything needs to have a purpose and make money" mentality here is very exhausting.
      • QuercusMax36 minutes ago
        I'd love to hear your critique of an art gallery
      • HerbManican hour ago
        There are so many projects that come up here that have the tag line of "This is such a stupid idea that I just had to do it!".

        We can do things just for the fun of it. Woz made the Apple computer basically as a toy, nothing more. And that's cool.

      • blks4 hours ago
        For fun.
      • wat100004 hours ago
        We could say the same for most of the comments on this site, including yours and mine.
      • _Microft4 hours ago
        Because they can.
      • nothinkjustai3 hours ago
        Are you useful?
        • fragmede3 hours ago
          That's the scary part about AI and the transformation it'll have on society. The answer to that question for all of us, soon enough, will be no, not useful enough vs an AI. Then what happens?
          • nothinkjustai3 hours ago
            Maybe, but it’s not gonna be because of LLMs
  • ConanRus3 hours ago
    [dead]
  • shevy-java4 hours ago
    Yet I still can not use ruby on it ...

    Sorry guys - Haiku is a great idea, but it needs to become a real operating system semi-advanced users can use daily. And it hasn't been at that since years.

    Linux works.

    • Tiberium4 hours ago
      What do you mean by that? It seems like there's Ruby in the packages:

      https://depot.haiku-os.org/#!/pkg/ruby/haikuports/haikuports...

    • trevithick3 hours ago
      > it needs to become a real operating system semi-advanced users can use daily

      No it doesn't.

    • OhMeadhbh2 hours ago
      It's completely okay for people who are not you to have requirements and preferences that are not yours. If you don't like HaikuOS, don't use it.
    • 4 hours ago
      undefined
    • rvz4 hours ago
      > Linux works.

      Which distro?

      Linux is an OS kernel, not a full operating system.

      I still need to know which distro to choose before I install it.

      No need to do that with macOS or Windows, but Linux is always a problem.

      • binaryturtle3 hours ago
        I have no idea which distro to choose actually. Too much choices and it's not clear why one should be better than the other. For some distros it feels more like it's one-man projects for bragging rights. It's also a bit hard to put trust in that.

        I want to resurrect an older Mac mini with an installation of a Linux distribution, but choosing a suitable distro is the first step I struggle with. Only thing I know is that it won't be an Ubuntu setup. :-)

        I do run Linux-based systems in various forms already: OpenWRT on the router, an older Debian VM —which I just messed up a few days ago by trying to uninstall a wallpaper package which took down the whole desktop environment for some reason— and Raspbian on the PI.

        But on some days I feel maybe I just should go for FreeBSD. But it may have similar (to a lesser extend) issues like Haiku with proper up-to-date software, especially in the web browser department? I previously dabbled with Haiku and this was its main issue. The OS itself is pretty nice though.

        • jonhohlean hour ago
          You should just go FreeBSD, but expect to have to learn along the way. My FreeBSD install is about 20 years old and still going well. It started as an Athlon 80GB NAS and has grown into 16-core and 12TB with Linux VMs for LLMs on a dedicated NVME. It would be nice if more worked natively on FreeBSD, but the things that work work great.
        • aniviacat3 hours ago
          I've tried a few distros in the past and have now settled (on NixOS for servers and tinkering, and Fedora for just-working). But I've never tried a BSD and would also be curious how using one would turn out.

          Maybe getting into FreeBSD for a bit would be a fun little project.

          • mghackerlady2 hours ago
            FreeBSD is infinitely better than any flavour of Linux if you can do what you need to on it. Great performance, superb documentation, the software just works for the most part (an update in the libc isn't going to break any of the base packages, for example). It takes a while to get it set up, and it can be picky about hardware, but I totally recommend
      • OsrsNeedsf2P3 hours ago
        Which Windows?

        I personally always install LTSC because there's no ads and less bloat, but sometimes random things don't work. This isn't a problem with Android, but Windows is always a problem

  • 4 hours ago
    undefined
  • OsrsNeedsf2P4 hours ago
    On VMs*
    • GranPC4 hours ago
      No, they got it booting on bare metal a few posts down.
      • OhMeadhbh2 hours ago
        Though I think it also boots in a VM if that's your preference. Also very cool that it's on real hardware.
    • ndiddy4 hours ago
      If you scroll down, the poster got it running on real hardware.
      • shevy-java4 hours ago
        Can we use that as daily driver?

        A clever developer making things work on his or her own hardware, is not quite on the same level as daily driver. (Granted, Linux would also have to run on M1 Macs. But I mean this more on the issue of same-hardware or comparable hardware level.)

        • altairprime4 hours ago
          One can reasonably infer that, since this is a discussion thread rather than a formal support announcement, that this is not yet a formally-supported configuration.
        • selectodude4 hours ago
          I’m not sure anybody can use Haiku as a daily driver, regardless of platform.
          • SyneRyder3 hours ago
            Depends on your needs. On Intel and for some minimal uses, it probably can be a daily driver. There's some days where I've used Haiku exclusively. Not many, and probably days when I went without checking my email, but it has happened.

            But it isn't ready for any kind of real mainstream daily driver use, no.

        • iAMkenough3 hours ago
          Who is “we” and why do they matter in this context
        • 4 hours ago
          undefined