15 pointsby daveoshawrus6 hours ago7 comments
  • daveoshawrus28 minutes ago
    Really appreciate all the valuable feedback from everyone so far. New puzzles are published every day, so feel free to play more during this week and let me know what you think. Thanks everyone.
  • limbero4 hours ago
    I did the " Separated by a Common Flame" puzzle (you're doing something funky with copy/paste so I had to right click to copy the title and all the clues).

    It's fun, but I have some pointers.

    1. Try to follow NYT's cluing rules, like plural clues always have plural answers. I was tripped up by "Bark pieces soaked before scattering over coals (8)" having the answer WOODCHIP.

    2. It's very difficult. I solve NYT pretty handily 7 days a week, and difficult crosswords in Swedish too, but I ended up using 21 hints, and not only because I rushed. The lack of crosses makes it a lot harder to get a lock on the grid.

    3. There was some questionable cluing in general, like "Shredded cabbage side at every British barbecue (8)" for COLESLAW, which I would not consider a particularly British side, and "Shallow inflatable pool beside the barbecue (8)" for PADDLING. Omitting the noun for that type of compounded adjective-noun word is fine I guess but felt clunky.

    I like the gimmick itself though!

    • daveoshawrus4 hours ago
      Thanks, I appreciate the feedback! I'll look into the plurality issue.
  • BoiledCabbage3 hours ago
    Nice to try something different.

    My feedback was it seemed like it was interesting to make, but for me at least not really interesting to solve.

    It felt more like solving two crosswords than a single combined one.

    Places where lots letters are shared between the two make it interesting, but they're weren't many. Sharing a single vowel 'e' isn't too interesting. Otherwise the just share the length which I already know the length for a crossword clue.

    It seems like there is a cool idea in there and keep working on it, it just isn't there for me yet.

    • daveoshawrus3 hours ago
      Thanks for the feedback. The additional factor which changes it from just two crosswords which happen to have the exact same grid is of course the shared letters as you said (the amount of these varies from puzzle to puzzle), but also it's that the clues are fully themed internally and connected to the other theme. Obviously I appreciate that it's not necessarily for everyone, and I appreciate the honest criticism. Cheers
  • yuppiepuppie3 hours ago
    Nice!

    This would be a perfect entry for https://hnarcade.com

  • brenschluss3 hours ago
    The “featured on scrolllaunch” banner covers the keyboard.
    • daveoshawrus3 hours ago
      Thanks, yes that was a quick error I had to fix, hopefully works now. probably shouldn't be adding badges on launch day ha.
  • oidar4 hours ago
    Doesn't load on latest firefox.
    • daveoshawrus3 hours ago
      Would you mind trying now? If it still doesn't work, it could be Firefox Enhanced Tracking Protection blocking Supabase. Thank you for the feedback.
    • daveoshawrus4 hours ago
      Thank you, I appreciate the feedback, I'll check it out.
  • mcflysj2 hours ago
    [dead]