1 pointby medv6 hours ago3 comments
  • jleyank5 hours ago
    I suspect Gresham’s law kicked in years back. Some people have things to say but they’re not interested in the current state of internet comments. Particularly if their topic is esoteric or, horrors, seen as controversial.

    And ai commentary is a waste of electrons.

    • medv5 hours ago
      > And ai commentary is a waste of electrons.

      What is it?

  • Bender4 hours ago
    Personal Blog Should Have Comments

    A spammer would agree. Trolls most certainly agree. If I was to add the function to comment it would use local storage. [1] not my repo

    If I wanted interaction from visitors I would make one of my forums public. They would at least have to register and they would be subject to normal moderation. As a new member only I would see their comments until their rank moves up from Guest, thus weeding out most low effort trolls and grifters.

    If I really wanted to hear from random visitors of a blog I would give them a throw-away email address or a form to contact me.

    [1] - https://github.com/tessalt/echo-chamber-js

  • 7bit5 hours ago
    > "Comments are too hard to host."

    > No.

    > They are just uncomfortable to host.

    That's being pedantic.

    Uncomfortable and hard can be used interchangeably. Both is true.

    Comments need a database, that is objectively harder than using Jekyll or the other examples you give.

    Comments need protection, otherwise you get bombarded with spam. That alone is a ridiculous amount of "hard".

    Or you outsource this part, but you critisise that, too.

    And even then, you still need moderation. Removing all the off-topic comments, the hateful comments, everything that doesn't belong.

    I agree with you, that blogs with comments and discussions are lively and can add more value to a post.

    But the statement that it's not hard is objectively false.

    • medv5 hours ago
      > Comments need protection, otherwise you get bombarded with spam. That alone is a ridiculous amount of "hard".

      This is not that hard. But your mileage may vary.

      > Comments need a database, that is objectively harder than using Jekyll or the other examples you give.

      Are we engineers or not?

      > But the statement that it's not hard is objectively false.

      Yes, I agree.

      People spend hours polishing personal websites. I want to encourage building comments systems! This is as fun and as valuable!