9 pointsby mpweiher7 hours ago5 comments
  • khelavastr3 hours ago
    Nobody holds teachers and school administrators accountable. If administrators' bad policies were persistently criticized and mocked at the school level by students, and adminsitrators' families were scorned for supporting local failure and degeneration, districts would change..
  • aebtebeten5 hours ago
    > "Teach in small groups."

    this advice sounds like it could fix many, many other issues as well?

    • gsf_emergency_65 hours ago
      Except the scaling ones..

      (Where I went to school, they taught us, parallel to reading, how to analyse propaganda. You can imagine the unintended consequences XD)

  • silexia2 hours ago
    Teachers unions have led to promotions and raises for bad teachers, and demotivation for good teachers. https://www.heritage.org/education/commentary/new-naep-test-...
  • bell-cot7 hours ago
    I'm sure "Why Boys Are..." gets the clicks - but if you actually care about fixing the problem, in a country where gender differences & favoritism are political hot buttons, and even students at elite universities are poor readers - then maybe start by framing things differently?
    • mpweiher3 hours ago
      It doesn't.

      "...while average scores have declined for everyone, boys are doing much worse."

      And it definitely doesn't get the resources.

      "But in contrast with efforts to encourage girls in math and science, which have helped shrink their achievement gap with boys, little attention or effort has been focused on improving boys’ reading skills."

      We've been framing things the same way for decades now, ignoring boys. Maybe it is time to frame things differently.

      Unless you also think that boys just don't matter.

      • bell-cot36 minutes ago
        Sadly, it sounds like you're all-in on making it a zero sum, us-vs.-them game. If not declaring a war over resources in the Education-Industrial Complex, then condemning anyone who's reluctant to take up arms for your cause.

        Vs. over 100 years ago, my grandmother taught 1st through 8th grades. In a one-room schoolhouse. Rural community - maybe 1% of parents had been to college. Annual per-student funding was $50-ish. Grandma's teaching credentials were, at best, a 2-year "Normal School" degree. The School District's Superintendent was probably 1/4 time or less, with zero administrative staff.

        And yet the vast majority of grandma's students left her 8th grade able to read at that level. Old family stories from the era have neither "boys vs. girls" subtexts, nor zero-sum worldviews.

    • tolerance6 hours ago
      What would you recommend?
      • ZeroGravitas4 hours ago
        How about saying that average reading performance is falling for all students? And that it's important to reverse that trend to have a better society.
        • tolerance3 hours ago
          Do you object to the headline for the same reasons as the person above? Do you have an issue with the article itself?

          I’m not trying to be provocative. I’d only like to know what you think. If there’s a legitimate reason to single young men out in this issue then what’s wrong with that?

        • mpweiher3 hours ago
          "...while average scores have declined for everyone, boys are doing much worse."