45 pointsby bakigul12 days ago4 comments
  • tefkah12 days ago
    I struggle to find non-evil applications of voice-cloning. Maybe listening to your dead relative's voice one more time? But those use-cases seems so niche to the overwhelming use this will likely have: misinformation, scamming, putting voice actors out of work.
    • apwheele12 days ago
      I would clone my own and do things like create scripted tutorials/presentations and audio books.

      I do not personally prefer it, but a non-trivial number of individuals like video/audio presentations over writing.

      • testing2232112 days ago
        I’m currently recording my books into audiobooks the old fashioned way. I wonder good indistinguishable this would be.
    • solarwindy12 days ago
      The possibility to continue to sound like yourself after permanently losing your voice (e.g. from motor neurone syndrome) is one. Perhaps almost the only one.
    • yellowapple11 days ago
      Video game mods are the first use case that comes to mind for me. If you want to add new voice lines for a character, your options are:

      1. don't (keep it silent);

      2. recruit the original VA somehow;

      3. recruit an alternative VA (who hopefully sounds close enough to the original to not be jarring);

      4. splice voice lines together from existing voice lines; or

      5. use text-to-speech.

      Voice cloning is just Option 5 but with results much closer to Options 2 and 3.

    • socks12 days ago
      At my workplace, a colleague in another team used an AI tool to voice/video clone my companies CEO, CRO and CTO (I assume with their permission) and created a mandatory 30 minute training video that they expected us to watch with these monotone fake company leaders doing the presentation. It wasn't even a joke.
    • schlupfknoten12 days ago
      Voice acting for procedurally generated games?
    • c0balt12 days ago
      Selling a voice profile for procedural/generated voice acting (similar to elevenlabs "voices") of a well-known person or pleasant sounding voice could be a legitimate use-case. But only iif actual consent is acquired first.

      Given that rights about ones likeness (Personality rights) are somewhat defined there might be a legitimate usecase here. For example, a user might prefer a TTS with the voice of a familiar presenter from TV over a generic voice.

      But it sounds exceedingly easy to abuse (similar to other generative AI applications) in order to exploit end-users (social engineering) and voice "providers" (exploitation of personality rights).

      • pogue12 days ago
        Eleven Labs pays the estate of the people's voices they use, correct?

        I have their app on my phone and it will read articles in Burt Reynold's voice, Maya Angelou's voice & etc. I'm under the impression that they consented to this and their estate's are being compensated (hopefully).

    • dyauspitr12 days ago
      If you want to make a podcast but don’t want to spend the time reading out the script and then painstakingly audio engineer every part of it.
      • kevinrineer12 days ago
        Why would you want to make a podcast then? You don't need to offer a sub-optimal product if you don't want to make it.
        • dyauspitr12 days ago
          I like writing out the scripts and doing the research. I don’t enjoy cleaning up the audio.
    • octoberfranklin10 days ago
      Resisting involuntary biometrics.

      If you're in the USA, your credit card company captures your biometric voiceprint without consent or even notification when you call customer service. This technology makes that pointless.

    • nailer12 days ago
      In Descript it is used to patch words in videos.

      Last year I proudly said it was "two thousand and five" during a video take, and didn't notice it at the time. I was able to add the "twenty" using Descript.

    • suburban_strike11 days ago
      Parody, but it toes the line of evil in being fake.
    • chistev12 days ago
      Black mirror episode
  • Bender12 days ago
    Anyone Can Clone Your Voice Now

    A good reason to let any caller ID one does not recognize go to voice mail. Phones need an app that does voice-to-text-to-voice to prevent capturing the voice. I want mine to sound like Smeagol (LoTR).

    • nailer12 days ago
      I'm pretty sure Caller ID is forgable and would lead to false negatives.
      • Bender12 days ago
        Then the only winning move is not to play. Everyone goes to voice mail and or all communication is in person. Perhaps these fondle slabs were indeed a fad.
        • nailer11 days ago
          Or just not use PSTN.
  • bigbuppo12 days ago
    Yes, but can they be as annoying as I am? I think not.
  • pogue12 days ago
    They couldn't already do that? Or is this new Qwen model just that much significantly better?