US Army Poorly Prepared for Arctic: Finnish Forced Surrender During Exercise(militarnyi.com)

25 pointsby saubeidl4 hours ago2 comments

xvxvx4 hours ago
‘The organizers of the exercises were forced to ask Finnish reservists, who were playing the role of the enemy, to go easier on the Americans.’
Since World War II, the U.S. has fought five major foreign wars (Korea, Vietnam, Gulf War I, Iraq, Afghanistan), with a poor win rate of about 1 win (1991 Gulf War) and 4 non-wins (draws or losses). In smaller interventions or “gray zone” conflicts, the pattern worsens: 9 wins, 8 losses, and 42 draws out of 59 cases. This creates a perception of frequent losses.
- B1FIDO3 hours ago
  Since World War II, the U.S. has mostly been fighting asymmetric warfare against insurgents and guerillas. This has caused a paradigm shift in our armed forces, to be more prepared for these types of conflicts, for street-to-street fighting as in Fallujah, and wary of threats like IEDs and suicide bombers.
  Perhaps our pivoting has left them less prepared to fight conventional warfare on open battlefields against symmetric adversaries? I don't know.
- pqtyw3 hours ago
  That's not really very fair. Besides the "draw" in Korea all the other defeats were political rather than military. Second Iraq war is more of a pyrrhic victory as well.
  - nis0s3 hours ago
    Is it a victory at all if it’s not political? Then what are you trying to accomplish? These are rhetorical questions. The problem is that leaders or frameworks have not been able to adapt as fast as technological progress.
catlover762 hours ago
[dead]