Google's "AI Ultra" Is a Storage Plan Disguised as a Dev Tool(one.google.com)
3 pointsby basher4 hours ago2 comments
  • gnabgib4 hours ago
    Title: Google One: More storage and Google AI in one subscription
  • basher4 hours ago
    I’ve been paying $125/mo (promo pricing for the $250/mo tier) for Google’s top-tier “AI Ultra” subscription for about a month.

    I signed up because I’m a power user. I manage large repos, build my own MCP tools, and live in the terminal. I assumed “Ultra” meant “Pro Developer.”

    I was wrong. I downgraded to the $20/mo plan today. Here’s why other developers should probably avoid the top tier.

    The “Double Pay” paradox

    The subscription gives you:

    The Web UI (Gemini Advanced)

    30TB of storage

    It gives you:

    Zero API credits

    If you use modern AI coding tools like Aider, Cursor, or your own CLI scripts, you still pay per-token for the API.

    My bill:

    $125/mo for the subscription

    ~$50/mo for API usage

    Reality: I was effectively donating $125/mo to Google for a Web UI I barely use, because I work in the CLI.

    The “official” CLI is broken

    I tried to use the official gemini-cli to avoid API costs. It’s unusable for agentic work.

    There’s a known, persistent bug where the CLI crashes with a 400 Bad Request error whenever the model attempts parallel tool calling (a standard model feature).

    Error: “Please ensure that the number of function response parts is equal…”

    These issues have been open for months:

    Broken auth: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/11925

    Parallel tool crash: https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/13292

    Shipping the org chart

    The pricing only makes sense if you look at Google’s internal structure:

    Google One wants to sell storage (30TB bundle)

    Google Cloud wants to sell APIs (Vertex)

    DeepMind wants to ship models

    “AI Ultra” is a Franken-product stitched together by the storage team. There’s no billing concept for “individual developer who needs API credits,” so instead you’re forced to buy a data center’s worth of hard drives.

    The feedback black hole

    There’s no way to get this feedback to someone who can act on it. You can’t file a ticket that says “your pricing model ignores developers.” You just shout into a generic feedback form.

    The fix: unbundle the intelligence

    What’s needed is a real Developer Tier:

    Give me: high API rate limits + API credits

    Charge me: fairly for what I use

    Until that exists, I’ve downgraded to the $20/mo plan and moved the rest of my AI budget to Anthropic.

    • ironbound4 hours ago
      The number of times I've used GCP products and they barely work, really tells me normal engineers don't test the products only wizards that think things are functional.
    • chewz4 hours ago
      You are looking for Gemini Standard Edition that for $300 gives you $1000 API credits among other perks.

      Gemini CLI still isn't usable though despite higher limits.