Show HN: Remove your data from 100 platforms without signing up(www.offlist.me)

2 pointsby rahulkandoriyaa month ago4 comments

billsimmsa month ago
Is there any way that a potential customer for this service could be convinced that their data was actually removed from these 100+ sites and that they can be convinced what that really actually accomplished? Are there other sites that provide similar services and you could present a comparison showing the pros and cons of each service? If you could do those things then this might more interesting to me. But I have seen some data collection/data search sites that have an opt-out feature down at the bottom along with a disclaimer that yes, if you ask us to remove your data we will do that, BUT you must realize that does not remove your data from the other thousand or billion sites on the net that also have your data and this opt-out is going to do nothing to remove your data from any of them.
- rahulkandoriyaa month ago
  I really appreciate your response. Most companies are legally required to honour the data removal email request.
  Offlist is just a tool to make opt out process easier.
  Btw, I will be definitely looking more in to your feedback and update the app accordingly in the future.
codingdavea month ago
I wouldn't use this. First of all, you are asking for my information to generate the emails, so saying "no sign up" is one of those things that is technically true, but you are getting my data anyway. Secondly, it might not be an expensive subscription, but it is not free. So with those two stretches of the truth, I already don't trust you. And not trusting you, there is no way I'm letting anything you create run scripts in my mail clients.
If you are really wanting to provide this service, you would provide templates and let people fill in their own info.
- rahulkandoriyaa month ago
  I can understand your feedback. You’re right that “no signup” can still feel misleading if the app asks for name/email, even if nothing is stored. The intent was purely to pre-fill templates locally, but I agree that trust-wise, that distinction may not matter.
  One change I’m actively considering based on feedback like this is removing personal info inputs entirely and defaulting to: select platforms > generate email directly on your own email app/website.
  On pricing: the goal wasn’t to hide that it isn’t free, but to avoid subscriptions and data lock-in. The app is free to use to generate email removal requests for up to 3 platforms (+3 if you share with your social media). So the free user can generate email removal requests for 6 platforms(any 6 from the 100+ available platforms according to their priority).
  That said, I agree that even a small payment raises the trust bar significantly for a privacy tool.
  This feedback is helpful, and I really appreciate it. Feel free to let me know if you have any questions.
- rahulkandoriyaa month ago
  Edit: I have updated the app so it now asks for nothing and generates the removal email request directly. It made the user journey simpler. Thank you so much for your valuable feedback.
  - a month ago
    undefined
rahulkandoriyaa month ago
One thing that surprised me while building this was how much manual effort is involved if you try to do this carefully. Finding the correct contacts and writing compliant data removal requests. It takes around 29+ hours for 100+ platforms.
I’m curious how people here handle this today: fully DIY, scripts, or any tool?
jdbohrmana month ago
Was this written with ChatGPT lmao