30 pointsby rmason3 months ago11 comments
  • lexicality3 months ago
    The video[1] from the actual person that built it contains dramatically more info than this lazy SEO spam clickbait blog

    [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GB52wYgEa9A

  • dobladov3 months ago
    He literately mentions in the video (1:55) that the solar panels can not power the electric engine but support it.

    Clickbait article, that's not worth anyone's time.

  • Liftyee3 months ago
    Clickbait warning... The video that appeared at the top of the page (followed by a bunch of blank space, presumably blocked ads) featuring a superyacht is NOT about the yacht in the title, although it does also have solar panels.
  • stonogo3 months ago
    There is almost no real information here, not even the name of the engineer. The pictures are credited to "true north yachts", and searching for this reveals a patreon that talks a lot about sovereignty and also youtube growth hacking. There's a patreon (called truenortharchive, not sure what it's archiving) and there doesn't appear to be any substantial information about this actual boat.

    All available information seems to be in this youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bX5EraBZ0As

    There are a couple of shots of the plywood construction, but no hard information. At one point he shows the camera the power control interface, and at another he shows the outboard motor, both of which seem to be off-the-shelf at https://www.epropulsion.com/

  • zitterbewegung3 months ago
    YT link https://youtu.be/KKypmuc2adk?si=qRcWWtSv30G5fj_m This is really interesting since I could see this as a drone platform that could loiter near a target or just provide intel.
  • jeffbee3 months ago
    "Yacht that runs forever without fuel" has kinda been done, many times.
    • toomuchtodo3 months ago
      With wind? Sure. With solar PV? Only recently. You're still going to need a watermaker to make fresh water, and consumables for it, along with food, but with enough solar, it is very compelling when you might have challenges sourcing diesel (whether financially or logistically). Scratches the self sufficiency itch to an extent, sailing solarpunk style.

      (have yachting friends in the cruising around the world way, not the wealthy yachting way)

    • stronglikedan3 months ago
      Yacht != Sailboat
      • 3 months ago
        undefined
      • IAmBroom3 months ago
        Very big sailboat = yacht.
  • dzhiurgis3 months ago
    One of my dreams is to find dismasted catamaran with seized engines and re-power entirely with solar+batteries for local trips.

    By my estimate whole setup would cost less than a single marine diesel engine.

  • denuoweb3 months ago
    It's pretty crazy that the article does not state how many theoretical watts the yacht has. It looks like maybe 4,000 watts from the photo of the panels.
    • KaiserPro3 months ago
      The video that the person made has the stats. (see further up, its only about 8 minutes)

      From memory its a 5.4kw array with 8kw motor. At 400w it can (on a calm inland sea) cruise at around 3 knots. Top speed of ~9 knots.

      Its made from plywood so its super light. he wants to take it across the atlantic, which I think is brave given that its not got any compartments(that I could see in the video), so any breech means it'll sink in minutes.

      • seec3 months ago
        Brave or stupid ? What I could get is that he is a young fool looking for "freedom" where there is none to be found. The boat isn't even interesting anyway, it's a bit dumb to spend that much money on an inadequate power solution when a cheap refurbished ICE would have been just fine.
        • KaiserPro3 months ago
          > cheap refurbished ICE would have been just fine.

          I mean an outboard would do, but then you are limited by range, also its noisy as hell. Sure you _could_ install an inboard second hand cummings with 10k hours. but thats not cheap or easy.

          So you're left with outboard motors. They are cheap and don't vibrate the entire boat, but they are still noisy. Plus they aren't actually that much cheaper to buy than electric.

          but then there is the running cost, it'll be (at uk prices) about £3.50 an hour to run on diesel, vs £0 on solar.

          Plus all the extra space for not having to install fuel tanks.

          my issue is more that the hull is untested and doesn't look all that strong.

          • seec3 months ago
            Sure, if you plan on running the boat as a way to make money the total running cost would make sense, but it's just a leisure boat so the financial aspect isn't really good to start with. It's just a way to have fun while burning money.

            But yes the bigger problem is the hull, that clearly isn't ready for difficult situations and this is why I said that. If you just want to have fun it's not really worth it to spend all that money for mediocre capacity when you could have gotten a decent experience for much less.

            I really don't get it, a sail boat makes much more sense if you just want to have fun without relying too much on a noisy motor.

    • stonogo3 months ago
      The guy who made it says it has a 6kW motor, but does not reveal details about his battery or PV array. Based on that number and the brief view of the motor, I'm guessing he bought this: https://www.epropulsion.com/products/electric-outboards/navy...
    • eptcyka3 months ago
      I wonder how much battery storage it has. Would suck to only be able to use the sauna when the sun is shining at full blast anyway.
      • stronglikedan3 months ago
        good thing about boats is that they can move a lot of heavy batteries relatively easily
        • eptcyka3 months ago
          The boat is marketed as being lightweight.
          • IAmBroom3 months ago
            Relative statement.

            It may even require ballast, which the batteries can pull double-duty for.

        • lisbbb3 months ago
          Water + batteries, lol. What could go wrong?
  • ugh1233 months ago
    Most important number is missing: how much did it cost to make?
    • dzhiurgis3 months ago
      18 panels is like $1.3k. Same for inverter. Battery stars at $2k for 15kWh, but I'd go for used car battery, so perhaps $6k for 60kWh, much less if you got means to drop battery yourself. That leaves you with propulsion. While electric motors are pretty cheap, marine ones still seem at rip off. DIY solutions from China start at 3k and complete outboard is like 15k.

      So overall I'd say for $10k for power and another $5k for motor.

  • system23 months ago
    Infinite scrolling blogs are disgusting.
    • stronglikedan3 months ago
      Especially when it's so resource intensive that it makes my music skip, and then the page becomes unresponsive when I try to back out of it.
  • themafia3 months ago
    Forever. Or until your charge controller dies. Or your batteries fail. Or your plywood yacht hits a storm.

    The inanity of over fitting your design to one particular function and ignoring all others and then pretending you've achieved something significant. It really is a hallmark of this particular ideology.

    • IAmBroom3 months ago
      That's why I admire your hookups on the front of your car for oxen harnesses.
      • lisbbb3 months ago
        We do have tow trucks for a reason. Nuclear submarines are only limited by how much food they can carry and the overall endurance of the crew. Theoretically...