Show HN: MapScroll – Map a story from one prompt(www.mapscroll.ai)
10 pointsby shekharupadhaya5 days ago4 comments
  • rco87865 days ago
    It's a neat idea, but having a hard time getting useful results (the forever plight of AI). I asked about a road trip from Atlanta to Houston with 3-5 interesting stops along the way. First it sent me to south Georgia, then to northern Alabama, then finally going west. I asked it to refine and it sent me east to Augusta and then 500+ miles past Houston to a steakhouse.
    • shekharupadhaya5 days ago
      Thank you for the feedback! I completely get what you mean. This is exactly the issue with open-ended discovery use cases, the AI just isn’t at a point yet where it can be fully trusted for stuff like road trips or similar things. It’s also kind of an open question on which use cases can be sharper and which ones the AI will completely mess up.

      That’s why I’m positioning this more as a way to curate map-based content, where the AI is tasked with plotting something using the supporting data from your prompt, so it can give a more precise first draft. Then it can be refined more using the edit feature before sharing it with confidence. Instead of expecting it to magically handle any random map question. That whole space of “unknown unknowns” still needs to be explored.

      Not sure I explained that perfectly, but I’m figuring it out too. Definitely needs more brainstorming and experimentation.

  • yamatokaneko4 days ago
    I tried your example prompt with “Create a 1-week itinerary for XX trip” and was really happy with the results!

    It mapped out which day to visit where, which is usually the hardest part to visualize when planning.

    It reminded me of the first time I played around with Airbnb’s map + search UI.

  • ibdf5 days ago
    As a person who loves to research where I am going and what's on the way there.. this could save me a lot of time. It's not 100% accurate, but good enough for researching a trip, or locating places mentioned in an article.
    • shekharupadhaya5 days ago
      Yes exactly! That’s pretty much how I see it too. As of now, it’s not going to give you a perfect map every time, but if you’re researching a trip or trying to quickly plot places from an article (either pasted snippet or from web search agent), it does save a ton of manual hunting. I’m hoping the refine + reorder features make it even easier to dial it in. Thanks for sharing how you’d use it.
  • blinding-streak2 days ago
    Needs a demo of what a sample looks like.