49 pointsby nikodunk10 months ago8 comments
  • gnabgib10 months ago
    Discussion (1006 points, 13 days ago, 661 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43463200
  • slavik8110 months ago
    This was almost my experience when my dishwasher died last year. When looking for reviews and advice, everyone recommended Bosch. However, when I saw it had WiFi, I baulked. After a lot of humming and hawwing, I decided against the Bosch 500 solely because I didn't want a dishwasher with WiFi. The saleslady thought I was crazy.

    Instead, I got an equivalently priced KitchenAid KDFM404KPS1 and am quite happy with it, with only minor quibbles. One of the wheels on the bottom rack is attached to a movable row of prongs, and if you push the row too hard in the wrong direction, you can knock the wheel off. You can just pop the wheel back on, but it's an occasional mild annoyance. Aside from that, I have no complaints.

    • marcusb10 months ago
      For whatever it’s worth, I have a previous-generation Bosch 500 (no wifi.) I generally like it a lot, but it has similar minor annoyances (the top tray will come off its guide rail on one side, but that won’t be obvious until the tray doesn’t slide all the way back in.)

      In other words, I don’t think Bosch is any better in the “minor quibble” department.

  • wildrhythms10 months ago
    What scares me is if these appliances will connect to any open network in order to phone home without the user's consent.
    • Wontron10 months ago
      Eventually the cost of a 5G module and data plan will be low enough that these appliances won't need any help to phone home.
      • jsheard10 months ago
        You don't even need 5G when things like Amazon Sidewalk exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Sidewalk

        Echo devices serve as internet-to-sidewalk bridges by default so it's pretty extensive, Amazon claims >90% of the US population is covered.

        • badgersnake10 months ago
          If you have an echo, you’re probably not too worried about this.
          • jsheard10 months ago
            It doesn't have to be your Echo, a Sidewalk client can get low-bandwidth internet access through any Echo that it can reach over LoRa, which goes pretty far.
      • tylerflick10 months ago
        Then I will finally be able to use the full power of aluminum foil rolls from Costco.
      • dzhiurgis10 months ago
        And you won’t be able to do anything.

        That’s why regulating some base standards and labelling is essential.

    • FirmwareBurner10 months ago
      When was the last time you saw any open networks in residential homes? All wifi access points use WPA2 and passwords out of the box in the last 10+ years.

      There might be one from some random hotel lobby nearby or neighbor with a Windows Vista PC, but that's the exception nowadays, not the rule.

      • rpgwaiter10 months ago
        I know it’s not common but I’ve kept a client-isolated open wifi hotspot on my property for a long time. You never know when someone might be in the neighborhood and need a connection!

        So far, a single client has connected in 4 years and I can’t remember if that was me or not.

        • frizlab10 months ago
          I used to do that but now I have put a password on my guest wifi with a QR code for easy typing (which I still have not printed; I should do that one of these days).
      • cptskippy10 months ago
        They won't even have to be open. ISPs like Comcast have been offering the ability to connect to Comcast hotspots that are just running on consumer's routers.

        How long before they offer that as a service to 3rd parties like Bosch or LG?

      • fuzzy210 months ago
        Just now, because Vodafone is running Wi-Fi hotspots on their customers' routers. (It's opt-out.)

        An appliance wouldn't be able to use that, of course.

        • FirmwareBurner10 months ago
          Those are not open but require in-browser authentication for customers.
    • theshrike7910 months ago
      There was an anecdotal story on Reddit about a Samsung TV that did this.

      The poster disabled WiFi on the TV and didn't add it to their own network. The TV kept complaining and re-enabling the wireless interface and eventually latched on to a neighbour's unsecured guest hotspot...

    • IvyMike10 months ago
      Just put your dishwasher in airplane mode...
    • twiceaday10 months ago
      There is money in them doing this nasty nonsense. The cost of something like a cellular connection will only keep dropping. Therefore, it is just a matter of time before such devices can connect to the internet without any way for the user to prevent them. Nobody is going to Faraday cage their house.
      • 20after410 months ago
        That’s where you’re wrong. I’m sure some people will indeed faraday cage their house (or their devices). I know that I’ll have wallpaper to match my hat.
  • api10 months ago
    Only regulation can fix this, because for the company it's nothing but upside. They can double-dip by selling data, gather data on their users, etc. There is no downside. There are nowhere near enough knowledgeable people who will balk at this stuff, and even if there are it won't matter if/when everyone does it.

    All economic incentives encourage maximum invasion of user privacy. That's almost universally true in my experience.

    • jjeaff10 months ago
      Regulation is maybe the most likely route, but the other is for customers to continue to vote with their wallet. if more and more people refuse to buy these listening devices, then they will stop doing it.
      • eszed10 months ago
        Can you point to any examples of this happening in the last decade or so?

        For now, I agree with the GP that:

        > There are nowhere near enough knowledgeable people who will balk at this stuff.

  • RobKohr10 months ago
    Yep, I got the same exact dishwasher because it was highly rated, and noped out of connecting it to the cloud.

    The only buttons I press though are power and start. Just make my dishes clean oh magic cleaning box.

    I also hate the touch buttons too. My favorites were the old washers with the big clicking square block buttons. I also like for the modes when you pushed one down, the others would pop up.

    Of course this was about 40 years ago, and such things are ancient history.

  • FloatArtifact10 months ago
    Your appliances are your next smart TV.
  • FloatArtifact10 months ago
    You know, my GE oven won't do the air frying mode without Wi-Fi.
    • mdaniel10 months ago
      I would deeply love an FTC complaint for false advertising if the box claims it has air frying but attempting to use it in your cabin in the woods doesn't

      ed: err, I guess under a different FTC, I guess

  • paulddraper10 months ago
    “I can’t wash the dishes because the Internet is out”
    • euroderf10 months ago
      I am surprised that nobody has tried to market some kind of "smart medication dispenser" that will leave people without their meds when the net is out.