Show HN: Uncloud – Uncomplicated container orchestration without control plane(github.com)
27 pointsby psviderski3 days ago1 comment
  • jackhalford2 days ago
    I don’t understand the storage story, imo different apps deal differently with replication and there’s no « one size fits all ». How are compose volumes replicated? Is split brain handled by corrosion or is it up to the uncloud user to set up stuff right in the docker compose?

    ps: I self host and have moved from compose to k8s on single node, kustomize helps keep app configs as DRY as possible

    • psviderski2 days ago
      I agree there is no one-size-fits-all for data replication. Currently Uncloud doesn't handle volume replication. Moreover it doesn't support regular Docker volumes yet, only mounting a host path. The reason is I didn't have time to give it proper thought on how to design volumes in a cluster context without getting into the full-blown PV support like in K8s.

      I suspect that I will implement support for regular local Docker volumes such that each service container will use its own volume on the machine it runs on. Uncloud won't automatically replicate data between volumes as storage replication adds significant complexity and potential failure modes. Apps that need HA such as databases can handle their own replication. I'm getting inspiration from Fly for this: https://fly.io/docs/volumes/overview/. Maybe it would make sense to implement handy commands for cloning, moving, and backing up volumes between machines, not sure yet.

      Corrosion (the embedded CRDT SQLite) is only used for Uncloud's internal state management, not for application data.

      • jackhalford2 days ago
        I see, so off the top of my head I’m thinking if uncloud could host some of my containers: nextcloud, plex, radarr, transmission, listmonk, linkding. And it seems its no better than my single node k8s, i.e they all have either sqlite or filesystems state, and no clear way for HA replication… mind you this isnt a problem of uncloud, moreso of the apps themselves
        • psviderski2 days ago
          Yep agreed, but on the other hand do you really need HA for them when you're perhaps a single user? I wonder, what motivated you to migrate to single-node K8s from Compose for your self-hosted setup?
          • jackhalford2 days ago
            No I don’t really need HA, for most of my services high availability comes last. I moved to k8s for learning purposes, I stayed because I like it. When I decide to move some services to HA I have a much more powerful base with k8s than compose.