81 pointsby geox4 days ago17 comments
  • araes4 days ago
    Anybody have the actual paper? Found the actual publication in PNAS [1] and the author's page that has some of the prior work on lava zones [2], just not much about the actual paper or water reservoir area they're discussing. Looks like it went to conference back in 2023. Be nice if these folks had a pre-print server like Arxiv...

    [1] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2415155122

    [2] https://pages.uoregon.edu/leif/markdown/

    • SpicyUme3 days ago
      Making a guess reading the article, I'd say near Clear Lake, possibly as far south as Waldo lake and as far north as Breitenbush hotsprings. Although it looks like the claim is that similar amounts of water could be found under other regions in the Cascades. Both lakes are very deep and impressively clear, Clear lake has trees at the bottom that were killed in the creation of the lake when the volcano nearby erupted relatively recently.
  • delichon4 days ago
    3x the capacity of Lake Mead is about 9x the current Lake Mead.
    • cwalv4 days ago
      Or .75x the capacity of lake tahoe
  • 1propionyl4 days ago
    Would have been better to not admit it was there or have hidden it.

    The last things we need are more clean water reserves sucked dry by Intel rather than it focusing on guaranteeing its own supplies through other means, or used as excuses for Southern California not to continue its (admittedly in some counties admirable) efforts to get water resource management under control in concert with other states in the watersheds.

    Resource curse.

    • pkulak4 days ago
      The fresh water that the PNW currently has access to is mind boggling. If it even comes close to being scarce, the whole world is probably in trouble.

      We irrigate millions of acres with the Columbia, and it’s still the largest river to hit the Pacific once it gets there. Every city gets their drinking water from their own personal watershed. No one needs to bother sucking water up from far below ground.

      • ahmeneeroe-v23 days ago
        From a per capita perspective you are probably correct, but there are a ton of people in eastern OR & WA that live within a few miles of the river and still have domestic wells into endangered aquifers.

        Additionally, there are a lot of farmers with ground water rights (ie wells) and not a ton with surface water rights (ie rivers).

    • westurner4 days ago
      TIL semiconductor manufacturing uses a lot of water, relative to other production processes? And energy, for photolithography.

      (Edit: nanoimprint lithography may have significantly lower resource requirements than traditional lithography? https://arstechnica.com/reviews/2024/01/canon-plans-to-disru... : "will be “one digit” cheaper and use up to 90 percent less power" )

      Datacenters too;

      "Next-generation datacenters consume zero water for cooling" (2024) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42376406

      Most datacenters have no way to return their boiled, sterilized water for water treatment, and so they don't give or sell datacenter waste water back, it takes heat with it when it is evaporated.

      From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42454547#42460317 :

      > FWIU, datacenters are unable to sell their waste heat, boiled sterilized steam and water, unused diesel, and potentially excess energy storage.

      "Ask HN: How to reuse waste heat and water from AI datacenters?" (2024) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40820952

  • westurner4 days ago
    How did it form?

    How does it affect tectonics on the western coast of the US?

    Cascade Range > Geology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cascade_Range#Geology

    https://www.sci.news/othersciences/geophysics/hikurangi-wate... :

    > Revealed by 3D seismic imaging, the newly-discovered [Hikirangi] water reservoir lies 3.2 km (2 miles) under the ocean floor off the coast of New Zealand, where it may be dampening a major earthquake fault that faces the country’s North Island. The fault is known for producing slow-motion earthquakes, called slow slip events. These can release pent-up tectonic pressure harmlessly over days and weeks

    The "Slow earthquake" wikipedia article mentions the northern Cascades as a research area of interest: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slow_earthquake

    They say water has a fingerprint; a hydrochemical and/or a geochemical footprint?

    Is the water in the reservoir subducted from the surface or is it oozing out of the Earth?

    "Dehydration melting at the top of the lower mantle" (2014) https://www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/science.1253358 :

    > Summary: [...] Schmandt et al. combined seismological observations beneath North America with geodynamical modeling and high-pressure and -temperature melting experiments. They conclude that the mantle transition zone — 410 to 660 km below Earth's surface — acts as a large reservoir of water.

  • suzzer994 days ago
    I think I speak for all LA residents when I say - DIBS!
  • Aloisius4 days ago
    81 teraliters according to the article.
    • ethbr14 days ago
      I have no idea what that means.

      How many Lake Meads is that equivalent to, for reference?

      • bradgessler4 days ago
        I want to know in units of lake Tahoe’s
        • Azerty99994 days ago
          I thought you were joking and I laughed, but then I read the article and it says "It also holds more than half the volume of Lake Tahoe".. hmmm..
          • bradgessler4 days ago
            I’ll trade you 18 lake Tahoe’s for one Lake Michigan.
            • ethbr14 days ago
              Michigan's alright, but there are superior lakes out there.
              • bradgessler4 days ago
                It’s very Erie when you say it that way.
                • ethbr14 days ago
                  What are you trying to say? Wanna fight about it?

                  Because I've got eleven fingers worth of lakes that say different.

                  • bradgessler4 days ago
                    Nope. I’ll just sea my way out.
                    • ethbr14 days ago
                      Way to keep your hud, son.
            • temp08264 days ago
              How many submerged Libraries of Congresses is that??
            • cozzyd4 days ago
              Michigan or Michigan-Huron?
  • idunnoman12224 days ago
    Oh yes, measuring things in Lake Meads. What is that even the only lake in California or something?
    • bruce5114 days ago
      To be fair, there is a connecting thread here.

      Lake Mead is the primary water display to a number of states. It's also pretty low (and getting lower).

      By comparing this resource to Lake Mead, it's making it relevant as a possible source of water. (Americans never found a resource they didnt want to exploit).

      Of course it's not as simple as that. Water in aquifers is different to water in lakes. And it's not clear if the aquifer water could be directed into the Colorado River. Or how easily it can be extracted from the rock. Or how quickly it will replenish.

      But the point is made. This is a lot of water that might be useful at scale.

      • bagels4 days ago
        Why would that water go to the Colorado River? There are a lot of mountains in the way of that idea.
      • hulitu4 days ago
        > Or how quickly it will replenish.

        This is, unfortunately, the last thing that matters.

    • alemanek4 days ago
      When you get to a certain volume you are required to use Lake Meads instead of Olympic Swimming pools as the unit of measurement. Look I don’t make the rules.
      • rich_sasha4 days ago
        What it is as a multiple of the size of Wales? Or how many storeys of a building?

        I'm lost without sensible units.

        • NikkiA4 days ago
          > Or how many storeys of a building?

          19, but only if you start with a ground floor

          • > 19, but only if you start with a ground floor

            With ground floor starting at 0 like in North America or at 1 as they have it in Europe?

            Bonus: How do you call an elevator in Japan?

              You press the button.
      • 4 days ago
        undefined
    • x3n0ph3n34 days ago
      It straddles the Nevada/Arizona border and sits behind Hoover Dam.
    • pryelluw4 days ago
      https://www.nps.gov/lake/learn/nature/images/Lake-Mead-Overv...

      I searched for that image. It gives me a good idea of the size.

    • bagels4 days ago
      It's not in California.
  • johnea3 days ago
    Awesome! In 4 or 5 years we should be able to drain that and let the aquifer collapse!

    +1 for gratuitous consumption!

  • 015a4 days ago
    This meme does not miss [1].

    > There is a global resource shortage.

    > Authoritarian state on the other side of the planet controls it.

    > US is finished.

    > American farmer in the middle of nowhere US discovers the largest supply of said resource known to mankind.

    > Repeat.

    [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/1e77yxp/it_keep...

    • insane_dreamer4 days ago
      and how does this apply to water?
    • bagels4 days ago
      We do keep finding new bodies of water. Unfortunately, they come in the form of hurricanes.
  • cedws3 days ago
    Any life down there?
  • 4 days ago
    undefined
  • awinter-py4 days ago
    okay but it is water instead of mead? would prefer mead
    • cardamomo4 days ago
      That's Mead Lake, you're thinking of, not Lake Mead
      • incanus774 days ago
        And I would've gotten away with it, too, if it wasn't for you meadling kids!
  • andrewstuart4 days ago
    Will now be exploited.
  • gosub1004 days ago
    ... Olympic-sized swimming pools...
  • jdlyga4 days ago
    ...and it's gone!
  • aaron6954 days ago
    [dead]
  • DueDilligence4 days ago
    [dead]